Last, I had mixed feelings that all the stories where from 3rd world countries (with the exception of India). Perhaps it was simple emotional overload. But after crying at the first three stories, I found myself less moved by the last three. Or perhaps it was the choice of the ordering of the 6 stories. I also found the sameness of style made the pieces start to lose some power as they went along. The idea we needed to see this through movie and TV stars eyes (as intelligent and well-intentioned as these women are) seems to really underestimate the intelligence of the audience.
I found myself frustrated listening to the feelings of the actresses about what they were seeing, and would gladly have traded that time for more interviews with experts in the fields, or the actual victims and those who are working for change.
The device of having female celebrities be our surrogate guide into each of these situations seemed odd and smacked of pandering. The elements that bothered me certainly didn't undercut the power of the film's message, but did make watching it less emotional than it might have been. "These situations are awful, but no situation is beyond hope and change" is the constant theme. So instead of feeling depressed you feel agitated and energized. In each case, we see a brave, almost saintly woman or organization fighting the odds and personal danger to change things. It does a great job of never downplaying the horrors of the subjects it tackles sex trafficking of under-aged girls, denial of education, genital mutilation, etc., while managing to always leave room for hope. You know a documentary has a real effect when immediately after watching you feel compelled to send money to two charities you've never heard of before. And even if arguably flawed on a film-making level, this is powerful, sometimes gut wrenching stuff. This four hour, two part PBS documentary on abuses of women in six different countries is taken from Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn's highly regarded book.
0 kommentar(er)
